I have more displays in my box-o-goodies, both OLED and LCD. The LCDs I have don't do graphics like this can though (which I will be utilizing). I didn't have another like the one that went bad, but I do have several smaller ones, 0.96", but with the same 64 x 128 pixels (SSD1306 controller). The top 16 rows of pixels are yellow and the rest blue. I have more work to show than you have seen, but all I needed to do was switch libraries, change a few lines of code, and they work the same with no changes in any scaling (but again they are too small now for my tastes).
I think I'll 3D print the enclosure for this display project so it sits under or on top of my GPSDO. I may yet still go with the OLED, I need to do some shopping. But if it fails - meh - I'll just port what I have over to some other graphics display and make another enclosure. It's not like it's mission critical stuff.