The principal reason for a remineralizer cartridge is TASTE and if you want to accuse me of not knowing about them then you are WRONG. It is part of what I do TASTE and in particular related to Tea and Coffee water. If the water is to pure the result tastes flat. Somewhere around 50-80PPM is best for Espresso while brewed drinks generally 100-150 PPM is about right. There is Nothing psuedo scientific about this at all and involves blind tastings again as part of what I have done for Roasting and Cupping training.
Oh, look a strawman. I took no issue with what you had to say about taste, in fact I quite agree. But you set that up as a strawman argument and proceed to 'demolish' that.
Stick to the substance of
my argument, not the one you've made up to replace it. How does purified water cause "
gut troubles due to the pH." as you claim? In what way is that claim anything but an old wive's tale?
Ditto the deleterious nature of purified water to humans, unless you have a diet so deficient in calcium and magnesium that you body is reduced to scavenging every last bit one can of each from drinking water? The recommended daily intake of calcium in the UK is 700mg, moderately 'hard' water is 100 - 200 mg CaCO
3 per litre which is equivalent to 40-80mg of calcium, thus one would need to drink 8.75 to 17.5 litres of water a day to make up the RDI by which point you would probably have passed the LD
50 of water which is 90g/kg (rat), so 6.3 litres for a 70kg man.
As far as osmosis inside the body is concerned - give me a break - one of the miracles of the kidney is its ability to selectively retain or discharge minerals according to need, it's not some chunk of Visking tubing that will always shunt minerals one way and water the other according to concentration. That's precisely why the kidney contains active transport mechanisms in addition to simple osmotic mechanisms. Reabsorption of Ca
2+ ions by active transport in particular is controlled by parathyroid hormone, and the levels of parathyroid hormone are controlled by blood calcium levels. Just drinking mineral deficient water is not enough to make you start literally pissing minerals away in fact, by the miracle of homeostasis, it will have exactly the opposite effect.