The amount of water is critical, and I've had to change it a little bit to get exactly the texture I like.
That's true for any bread type baking. A long time ago I switched to using "baker's percent recipes" for all my bread related baking. In a "baker's percent recipe" you call the quantity of flour you use "100 baker's percent" and then specify all the other ingredients as percentages - all by weight. So a straight bread dough recipe looks like this:
- Flour 100%
- Salt 2%
- Yeast (dried) 1.4%
- Water 65%
Yes, the numbers add up to more than 100% - we're dealing with Bakers, not mathematicians.
Once you start looking at the recipes like this the rôle of water in determining the characteristics of the finished product becomes really clear and you start thinking of the type of dough you need for a particular style of bread as a "percent hydration dough". Some examples:
- Beigels - 50%
- Typical English bread styles (e.g. Cottage loaf) - 60-65%
- Typical French styles (Baguette, Boule) - 70-75%
- Ciabatta - 80-100%
The hydration level you use has more effect than any ancillary ingredients or processes that might apply to a particular style of bread. You won't get pukka beigels without boiling them (ideally in a weak food grade potassium hydroxide solution), and you won't get pukka French style breads without using a Poolish (A Polish style pre-ferment) but if you get the hydration wrong but still use the ancillary ingredients/processes you won't get anything like the style you were aiming for. And yes, a 100% hydration ciabatta dough is 'interesting' to handle - one's first attempts will be more about cleaning up oneself and the kitchen than about baking.