I have watched several videos from GW-Instek on YouTube recently, and I wanted to share some general feedback on these videos, to hear what other forum users think about these videos, and possibly get feedback and more insights =)
Maybe there is also a product manager or an engineer from GW-Instek, who is an active member on this forum, and this way they can pass on the provided feedback in this post, towards the respective person or department that is responsible for the videos, and maybe even to the presenter itself!
So, here is my general feedback on these videos:
Feedback item 1: Comparison videos
===========================
In all of the comparison videos, the speaker keeps saying the full model number, both for the GW-Instek device, and for the competitor's device, during the entire video, every single time, over and over, and over.....
I really don't understand why, as it makes the video very hard to follow, and it just becomes ridiculous!
First, I thought, that this might just be for one or two videos, but in fact, it is in all of their videos.
Then I started to wonder, if this is a "GW-Instek" company culture thing, or if this could be a "Taiwanese" presentation culture thing?
AFAIK any teacher, educator, lecturer, or person holding a presentation, further referred to as presenter, normally starts with an introduction, where the model number is explained once in full detail, together with the type and function of the device.
After that single introduction, the presenter refers to the device with a shortcut name for abbreviation.
The videos would be so much easier to follow, if they would stick with the full model numbers in the introduction, and use the introduction also as an opportunity to provide brief information about the price range and feature set of the device, to properly position the device first against the counterpart competitor's device.
After a proper informative and concise introduction, they should really stick to the shortcut abbreviation in the remainder of the video, and only refer to "our spectrum analyzer", "the spectrum analyzer from X", "our oscilloscope", "the oscilloscope from Y".
If they want brand recognition, they could of course use "the GW-Instek spectrum analyzer", or to keep it a bit shorter, "the GW-Instek device".
If you think, that I am exaggerating, please do watch the videos about the GDS-2000A series, GDS1000B series, and GSP9300 series, and watch for yourself, and become mad after some very short time!
Gee Dee Es Two Zero Zero Zero Eigh, Gee Dee Es One Zero Zero Zero Bee, Gee Es Pee Nine Three Zero Zero Zero, ......................... Gee Dee Es Two Zero Zero Zero Eigh,
Feedback item 2: Demonstration videos
=============================
I really don't understand the goal and value of their demonstration videos.
They don't give an introduction, about what test they are going to do, what the objectives are of the test, what parameters that are used for the test, and what parameters they are trying to measure.
They just ramble a number of actions that you have to do, with random numbers and values,
which seems totally useless..... or does one need a hard copy of a story board or test script at hand, together with the videos, to understand and capture a single point of the video?
If they talk about a specific modulation type, why don't they first give an overview of all the modulation types that their device supports? Or maybe give a short introduction about the specific modulation type.
Use some graphics, slides, pictures. Use a white board. Make it more instructive.
GW-Instek is a big company, and they should have plenty of class rooms, with a big white board.
It's just unbelievable how the demonstration video is put together, and how they can even consider that it provides any value to the audience!
If you think, that I am exaggerating, please do watch the videos about the GSP9300 series, and check for yourself, and become mad after some very short time!
Demo kit for Gee Es Pee Nine Three Zero Zero Zero,
Option Control, Select F4, Press F1 Twice, Press Modulation, Select eF eS Kay, Press Frequency,
Four Three Three ....
Select Binary Code One Zero One Zero One Zero One Zero...... Sequence Five.....
Conclusion
=========
This is just too crazy for words!!!!!!
Appreciate if other forum users can take a look at some of their videos, and provide feedback.
Hopefully we can get hold of a GW-Instek product manager, engineer, or distributor that carries GW-Instek gear, and has contacts with the main office
Maybe this is their number, which the presenter would present as per below =)
1-800-GW-INSTEK, One Eight Zero Zero Gee Wee In Ste Ke
GW-Instek really has to get their act together on their comparison videos and their demonstration videos.