I'm using a HP 1743A on my 'random stuff' bench, and it's a nice scope overall. Mine has accumulated enough faults that it's due for some repairs:
- Scale illumination stopped working recently. The very even electron flood lighting is nice when it's working.
- The digital 'time interval' measurement system died a couple of months ago. But I rarely used it anyway.
- There's some slow intermittent variation of the vertical offset, both channels. THIS I need to fix!
- Channel B 50 ohm termination is open circuit. I expect this is a pretty common fault, due to people forgetting the termination was on, and blowing it up. (It wasn't me!)
My biggest complaint about these HP 174x scopes is that the front panel lettering and dial numbers are small and low-contrast, and unless the room lighting is bright and omni-directional, I can't read them without having a desk lamp (or torch!) directed at the scope face. The buttons tend to shadow their own labels.
Of course like all HP and tech equipment of that era, the biggest plus is the availability of service manuals complete with schematics, theory of operation, cal procedures, etc. Both original paper and pdf.