Well here is my front end for L/S band week signals,
Antenna ->
PSA4-5043+ LNA, +20db wide band, NF less than 1db -> Band pass filter, usually made or chosen (if bought) to be as narrow as possible for the application ->
PSA4-5043+ LNA -> +30db LNA made from removing filter and patch from an active GPS -> Downconverter if S band -> Airspy Mini SDR
I put the two wide band mini circuits LNA's in the front because they should bring down the whole receivers NF, and I would assume having a wide band LNA in front of the band pass filter instead of a more narrow band one there would help prevent any IMD. Im either using the receiver right at the antenna and sending over ubiquity radios or running LMR600 feed line.
At this point it all really comes down to the antenna performance, im sure the receiver could be better too but for now an AirSpy is good enough. I don't know how to use EM modeling software and I have so much going on its not really something on my short list to learn. Basically I just need to figure out the quietest antenna which allows for modest gain (as you can always add another to get more gain). I was really thinking a helix style would be it but ive had a harder time with them than I figured, maybe adding a quarter wave brim/shield around the ground plane would help improve some performance issues. Ive also been wrapping them around ABS pipe so im not sure what the dialectic constant of ABS is but that could be why the ones I see with more of an "air core" preform better?
Ive looked in to yagis too, but having to build more than one long boom circular polarized yagi just does not sound fun at all, and im not sure how much better a long boom yagi would be compared to a perfectly built helix anyway. I started with batch antennas but there gain pattern isn't all that great if you want to keep ground temperature out of the mix. So I guess the question is, is a few moderately sized horns going to be the best antenna solution, or are properly built helix antennas just as good?