Odd things with copper tape are often due to the thin top film used to reduce corrosion. If overlapping the tapes best is to solder the seam every so often to get good electric contact between them, either just a solder spot or use some wire soldered both sides.
To test if it is copper, CCA or plated steel use first a magnet, which will attract the steel. Then apply heat from a cigarette lighter, the copper will glow red and not droop, and the red surface will be noticeably softer when cold, and a lot easier to bend. CCA will melt and droop. Have not yet met copper plated nickel sheet, though it must exist, as an intermediate process to doing a full chrome or gold finish for things that are formed in a press from sheet or strip. Probably the cost of the base nickel is close to the cost of copper, so not a thing to fake.