The gain of this circuit is R2/R1 +1 = 56000/100 = approximately 560
You will have to adjust R1 ( make it higher to reduce the gain). The R13 could be changed also , but I show a method for calculating R1.
Check how much the resistance varies in the new ptc ,from the datasheet , for your temperature range of interest.
Using this ,calculate the maximum and minimum voltage at the positive node of opamp . (The ptc resistance and the 1M (R13) form a simple resistive divider) .
Use the maximum and minimum voltages at the input to calculate the opamp gain . Remember the output should not go near the maximum supply voltage of 5 and minimum voltage of 0 .
For ex . If maximum opamp input is 200mv and minimum is 10 mv ,your gain can be about 20 ( so the opamp maximum output voltage is 200mv * 20 = 4v ,and the minimum output is 10mV*20 = 200mV)
Thus R1 = approx 2.5K
https://www.electronics-tutorials.ws/opamp/opamp_3.html