So far I have been using mostly iTead for low qty pcb orders. Recently I decided to give Elecrow a try because of (don't laugh at me) free coloured soldermask.
I recently tried Elecrow a try for the exact same reason, so you're not alone
Going against common advice, I had a board done with black soldermask. It's pretty sharp but I think I'm partial to green. The board was well made and of good quality.
I was notified my board was "shipped" on 1 April, but a Hong Kong post tracking number wasn't provided until 6 April. I received the board on 12 April.