OshPark is really good and inexpensive but the quality can vary.
The attached picture shows the result using the same board files but ordered with two different orders about 24 hours apart. I doubt that any place could do better than the one on the left, but for my project the one on the right isn't something I would want to sell because the customer will be soldering the through-hole devices and I would be a little embarrassed by the plating not being aligned to the holes. Also the wavy outline won't even work for my project where it needs to fit tightly into a cutout of the same shape (the break-away protrusions don't matter). If I really needed to, I could order a panel and cut them out myself since I do have a CNC that could do that, but the misaligned plating is an issue for me.
I'm kinda new to all of this and so I may be a little naive to what can be done and may be way to picky.
I too would like to know of any place that provides the kind of consistent quality as shown by the board on the left, with ENIG, and colors besides green.