First thing on new drives run a full SMART surface scan, and if any reallocated sectors show up, or there are any pending ones, then suspect it. Will take hours, but the nice thing is you can do it using a USB2 drive caddy, as all you are transferring is control data. then install in the machine, format to what you want ( preferably a full format, so if there is any infant mortality it will occur on a blank drive) then scan again and see if the reallocated sector is grown or pending is higher. If so it is an infant mortality drive, so time to RMA it for failing SMART.
Good drives should go their entire lives with no reallocation, or only a few. If you are in the tens on a new drive it is not healthy. I had a few WD and Seagate drives that were DOA or which died during the scan. Much easier to change when it is only formatted and mostly blank and has a bad day.