Sorry, I have not read carefully... start of topic there was:
"1N914 diodes so I decided to try and build a simple am radio with one of them"
so I have this in mind when I write...
Your diode type is not problem number one
but also it is not best.. (if it is shottky 1N60... FV 0,3V @ 1mA (sure there do not go 1mA... in this case need think how diode work with extremely low current. (before I give link where can find really huge amount of theoretical AND practical information about crystal radio.. also about high Q resonant circuits and also what is effect of loading this resonant circuit. (oscilloscope probe btw destroy nearly all... if want measure HF LC resdonant circuits it really need also tools... not common scope probe. (yes it can use but it need understant what is LC+Probe circuit together.
Maybe your system loaded Q go very low. (detectorr load resonant circuit, antenna also maybe make heavy load. For HF (MW) frequencies need guite lot of wire for coil.. so it is better use litz (RF resistance is more low and loss is more low so Q go more high.) Also capacitor need be high Q. Many small "pocket radio style" tuning capacitors are not. One old solution is also (specially if can not use good capacitor or if need do "small" dimensions. (High Q 100...400pF capacitors are big... tens of years ago I use this permeability tuning. Fixed high Q capacitor and.... tuning with inductance. (you know... ferrite rod can move inside coil... yes it works also. (permeability tuning is not bad as we know also it is used in some professional receivers)
From old times I remember one 20cm ferrite rod and 80 turns coil... it was fun to listen some utility stations. (yes many of these use this time AM modulation)
It do not cost much of if you try forward biasing this diode... (this is classic "trick" from real life in time when there was no other radios)
example some small DCV through 10Mohm resistor to diode anode and also cut DC road to L with small capacitor. (of course best is do it with inductor for cut RF "road" but experimental test can do without...